Well, I really enjoyed Tyto's other suggestions...! You could use those.
For water: A trident would fit nicely here, I reckon. It can have an intricate wavy pattern etched on its pole, giving the illusion of flowing water!
For darkness: All I can think of is some form of gun..?. This can be simple as a pistol or revolver or as grand as a submachine gun... It can emit some sort of ominous projectiles as dark and rapid as a shadow.