Why Was Louis Riel Considered A Traitor? I Am Doing A Social Studies Debate And I Have To Defend Why He Was Bad. ?

3

3 Answers

Anonymous Profile
Anonymous answered
Louis is guilty of high treason against his country.  He led the Metis people and native groups to actively commit acts of war against his country.  He was the leader of the opposition and even he himself during his trial said he was guilty. He may have been an escape goat for the prime minister of the time so that he could get funds to build his railway and thus consolidate his role and unite the newly formed nation of canada but this does not matter.  He created a provisional government even though he had no right too and then proceeded to take up arms against the Canadian government.  In addition he is a murderer for killing Thomas Scott and he has no right to pronounce someone else a traitor even though Scott was foul mouthed and racist. He was not a legal representative of Canada nor a judge.  He is guilty even though he was a religious fanatic, which really has no bearing on the subject.  Louis is guilty.
Anonymous Profile
Anonymous answered
Me too! I also have to do a debate on whether he was a hero or traitor, and have to prove that he was a traitor. These are my reasons:
- betrayed his country and fled, then having the nerve to return and restart a rebellion, only before getting arrested, tried, and hung. The rebellion collapsed anyway, and he ran away.
- he led rebels attempting to secure land titles in Saskatchewan in Batoche (1885)
- he plead insanity at his trial ... He was insane, and was put in a mental institution a few times. Sometimes orderlies had to put him in a strait-jacket.
- he was an outlaw
I don't really think he was a hero or a traitor, but its a debate I have to do, so I guess that's all I have to offer :)
Anonymous Profile
Anonymous answered
Hey was bad because it was a ni wut that pooped him self

Answer Question

Anonymous