The end of the Reciprocity Treaty was as much a symptom of events as it was a cause. USA had a bloody war between the states in the preceding five years. Britain had given tacit support for the rebellious south. In the reconstruction aftermath, USA protectionists were able to leverage the lost trust, and deals with Britain were off.
The federal union was supposed to make Lower and Upper Canada more seamless, much as state lines in USA had traditionally been only inconsequential non-barriers to commerce. In such union a common pool of opportunities would open within Canada in which the whole would become something greater than the sum of its parts. Canada could then stand better on its own, economically and politically.
The issue of reciprocity became revisited periodically thereafter. A treaty was signed in 1911 but abrogated in a subsequent Canadian election charged with anti-USA sentiment. GATT in 1945 brought the phasing-out of tarriffs between the two countries. After another time of anti-USA sentiment in the 1980s, fueled by the acid rain controversy, Pres. Ronald Reagan and PM Brian Mulroney signed settlements on the environmental issues and a new Canada-USA free trade agreement in 1988. NAFTA expanded the North American free trade zone in 1993.
The basic and repeated historical pattern in Canada has been one of paranoia about being "absorbed" by the massiveness of USA while desiring the economic benefits of seamless commercial integration across the border.
The federal union was supposed to make Lower and Upper Canada more seamless, much as state lines in USA had traditionally been only inconsequential non-barriers to commerce. In such union a common pool of opportunities would open within Canada in which the whole would become something greater than the sum of its parts. Canada could then stand better on its own, economically and politically.
The issue of reciprocity became revisited periodically thereafter. A treaty was signed in 1911 but abrogated in a subsequent Canadian election charged with anti-USA sentiment. GATT in 1945 brought the phasing-out of tarriffs between the two countries. After another time of anti-USA sentiment in the 1980s, fueled by the acid rain controversy, Pres. Ronald Reagan and PM Brian Mulroney signed settlements on the environmental issues and a new Canada-USA free trade agreement in 1988. NAFTA expanded the North American free trade zone in 1993.
The basic and repeated historical pattern in Canada has been one of paranoia about being "absorbed" by the massiveness of USA while desiring the economic benefits of seamless commercial integration across the border.