" All manholes are circular in shape " is not true. Man Holes in Boilers are elliptical in shape. Even for sewer man holes rectangular in shape can be easily seen. But I agree that sewer manholes should be of circular shape.
Manhole, as the name suggests , is meant for a man to get in it and come out easily. A circular opening requires minimum surface area for a given maximum length that can be lowered.
For example if a man requires minimum of x cm opening to allow him to go into the man hole, Then a circular opening will need a surface area = π (x/2)² = (π/4) x² = 0.785 x² cm²
Now let us consider a square hole of side x cm. It has an are of x² cm² . The rectangular hole has still bigger area.
This clearly shows that Area of the opening providing the same maximum dimension is least in case of a circular opening.
Again if the two shapes of the man hole have the same thickness, and are of the same material, the quantity of the material (may be Mild steel plate or RCC) will be minimum for a circular hole. Ie it will be cheaper.
Dr. Pramod Kumar Tandon
Manhole, as the name suggests , is meant for a man to get in it and come out easily. A circular opening requires minimum surface area for a given maximum length that can be lowered.
For example if a man requires minimum of x cm opening to allow him to go into the man hole, Then a circular opening will need a surface area = π (x/2)² = (π/4) x² = 0.785 x² cm²
Now let us consider a square hole of side x cm. It has an are of x² cm² . The rectangular hole has still bigger area.
This clearly shows that Area of the opening providing the same maximum dimension is least in case of a circular opening.
Again if the two shapes of the man hole have the same thickness, and are of the same material, the quantity of the material (may be Mild steel plate or RCC) will be minimum for a circular hole. Ie it will be cheaper.
Dr. Pramod Kumar Tandon